What happens after you hit apply
Watch this part (14:15)QWhat actually happens when I hit submit?
It goes into the applicant tracking system, the ATS. Brett says ATS stands for "another tired scapegoat." It's mostly a place for applications to live, with filters. Applications usually show up in the order they came in. Recruiters can filter on the yes/no application questions, and some systems add a match score. Then a human checks.
QShould I apply late at night or first thing in the morning so I'm at the top of the pile?
Brett's answer: not a real strategy. The ATS isn't an inbox, and nobody gets pinged for every application. If you're emailing a recruiter directly, send it during working hours.
QApply first, or find a referral first? Is cold applying even worth it?
Apply first. Brett and Emily agree on this one. If it's not in the ATS, it's not a formal application. Emailing your resume doesn't count, and a posting can close any time. Then go find your people.
QWhy did I get a rejection 5 minutes after I applied?
Usually a knockout question. One of your answers on the application screened you out automatically: location, years of something, a must-have skill. That's a filter, not a person reading you and saying no.
QIf there's AI in the ATS, why does a rejection take months?
The AI isn't the one deciding when to send it. A person still has to close out the search. And Brett was honest: the hiring manager is the one paying him, so the hiring manager gets his attention first. That's why the "no" can take forever.
QWhy do I have to retype my whole resume into their form?
It's annoying, and it's still worth doing. Brett said recruiters can filter on application answers, so those fields can be what gets searched. Fill them in.
QI live far away but I'll relocate at my own expense. Why am I getting filtered out?
Location can be a knockout question. Emily's fix: add one sentence to the summary at the top of your resume saying you're relocating.
ATS scores, keywords and AI screening
Watch this part (19:39)QWhat ATS score do I need to get an interview? Are match scores even helpful?
There's no magic number. Brett said if everybody scores an 80 or a 90, the score is useless to him, so he has to find other ways to spot the strongest matches. Most recruiters Emily talks to don't trust the AI scores, so they still search by keywords themselves. And those online checkers that say "your resume scored 62%"? Emily's take: they're built to scare you into buying services.
QDon't stuff keywords, but get a high score? How?
Use the keyword, then prove it. Emily's rule: don't just list a skill. Write a bullet that shows when you used it and what happened. Brett said a perfect 100 out of 100 is often a bad sign, because it usually means keyword stuffing.
QIf the ATS filters by score before a human sees it, doesn't "un-generic-ify it" stop mattering?
No. Brett said even a 100 out of 100 doesn't go straight to the hiring manager. He checks it with human eyes first. The resume that gets past the filter is the same one a person reads next.
QHow is "overuse of AI" screened? Is the AI in the ATS getting smarter? How are we being judged by these tools?
Brett said some systems have features aimed at fraud, spam and overuse of AI. He didn't get into how they work, so we won't guess. What he did say: he can tell when AI wrote something, and what he's looking for is your point of view.
QIs recruiting keeping up, including for neurodivergent candidates?
Brett coaches a lot of neurodivergent folx, and he called AI an accommodation. He's for using it. His warning was about letting it erase your point of view.
Pivots and transferable skills
Watch this part (25:53)QHow hard will a recruiter work to see my transferable skills? Does screening favor people who've held the exact same job?
Brett gave the honest answer: if he has 20 exact matches, those go to the hiring manager first. He can see how your skills transfer... but after 100 resumes he's tired, and you're asking him to do the translating. So do it for him.
QHow do I describe transferable skills moving into government, nonprofit or social impact?
Emily's method: study a stack of postings for the role you want. Ask AI for the top skills and pain points. Then rewrite your past jobs in their language. Her client leaving ed tech stopped saying "students" and started saying "stakeholders." You can't be subtle on a resume.
QShould I change my resume for different roles, even if what I've done hasn't changed?
Yes. What you did stays the same. How you describe it should match the job you want next.
QMy role's the same, but my industry is shrinking. How do I move?
Same method as any pivot. Write your experience in the new industry's words.
QSo should I only apply for jobs where I'm an exact match?
No. But know which pile you're in. Exact-match jobs are where an application does the most work on its own. For a stretch role, your resume is up against those 20 exact matches, so a referral or a person who knows you matters a lot more.
QShould I apply when I have most of the skills, like a job that combines two roles?
Yes, if you can do the core of it. Watch the must-haves in the application questions, since those can be knockouts. If you clear those, apply, and make the overlap obvious near the top of your resume.
QMy state requires a set number of job-search activities a week, and that basically means cold applying. How do I balance that?
Keep a fast, simple version for the ones that check the box, and save your real tailoring time for jobs you'd be happy to get a call about. Check your state's rules on what counts, since it varies.
Gaps, contract work and red flags
Watch this part (31:20)QHow are recruiters looking at gaps right now?
Brett: you're not alone. Lots of people have gaps, for all kinds of reasons, including the market itself. What hurts is hiding it. He hates finding out in a call that the job at the top of your resume ended 6 months ago.
QHow should I explain a gap or a red flag, like relocation or a step down after layoffs?
Emily: one short line, on the resume itself. Add a sentence to your summary at the top, or put it right after the job title and company: "Laid off due to company restructuring." Done. The recruiter's already wondering, so answer it. Brett added: don't count on the cover letter to explain it. He reads the resume first and may never get to the letter.
QI took a caregiving break and did some consulting. Do I name the break or fold it into the consulting?
If the consulting is real and still going, Brett said "through present" is fine. For the break, Emily's example line was "Left job to take care of a family member." Simple and true.
QDo recruiters count freelance or contract work as real experience?
List it like a job: the client or type of work, the dates, and what you got done. Brett said consulting "through present" reads fine. We passed the "does it make me look like a flight risk?" part to Brett.
QMy resume writer put my certifications at the top to show I've been busy during a long gap, and my experience doesn't start until the bottom of page 1. Good idea?
Showing what you've been doing is smart. But Brett reads the resume first and doesn't have time to hunt. Try one line about it in your summary instead, and keep your experience high on the page.
QWould you add an explanation line if you were fired?
Not on the resume. Save it for the conversation, and have a short, calm answer ready.
Cover letters
Watch this part (41:52)QAre cover letters read? Why do companies ask for them if nobody has time? Are they useless?
Brett: they're fine, and most of them sound exactly the same. He reads the resume first. The cover letter that actually matters to him is a note from someone referring you, because their reputation's on the line. It's also why you're seeing more application questions instead of letters.
QAny way to stand out in one? Should I just have AI write it, since it doesn't matter?
Emily: skip the generic AI version. Use a letter when you have something to explain: a pivot, a gap, a red flag. Keep it to half a page or less. The role, where you found it, what they need, and 2 or 3 bullets showing you've done exactly that.
Using AI on your resume
Watch this part (45:55)QCan recruiters tell when AI wrote it? Does it matter?
Brett: he uses AI. You use AI. Everybody does. The problem is sameness. If everyone hands the hard part to AI, nobody stands out. What he notices is whether you told your story from your point of view, because AI doesn't have one.
QHow do I stand out when everyone has the same skills?
Emily's fix: give the AI the story behind each bullet first. What you did, what changed, the context, and the numbers. Then let it help you tighten it. It can't invent your impact. You have to bring that.
QIf I detail my accomplishments, my resume gets too long. Half the advice says detail everything, half says leave them wanting more.
Deb's answer in the chat: be honest. Is every bullet proving you can fix the problem they're hiring for? Or is it more proof than they need? A lot of us have resumes packed with decades of work, and we're attached to it. That part's for us. They're looking for their specific match.
QIs there a good AI I can ask whether my resume or LinkedIn looks good?
Any of the big ones work: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini. What you give it matters more than which one you pick. Try the prompt at the bottom of this page.
QDo auto-apply tools work? Is LinkedIn Easy Apply ever successful?
Brett said one-click applying is a big reason the piles got so huge. It's easier than ever to apply to 100 places, so each application gets less human attention. If a friend got interviews from a tool, good for them. We'd still put most of your time into applications you'd be glad to get a call about.
Reaching recruiters (and the ones reaching you)
Watch this part (52:31)QHow do I connect with recruiters and build a real relationship, not a one-and-done?
Brett: follow them (it's free) and leave thoughtful comments on their posts. Not "great post." An actual thought. Emily: find the recruiters in the industries and companies you want, follow them, engage, and let them learn your name before you ever pitch.
QEmployers are replying to my comments on LinkedIn. Can that help me get noticed?
Yes. Brett said a thoughtful reply to his post is the thing he loves. Keep going.
QWhat should a message to a recruiter say?
Apply first. Then keep it short and spell their name right. Emily: the job, the req number, where you found it, and a couple of reasons you're qualified. Brett's don'ts: don't ask when your interview is, and don't send your Calendly link. And don't send a connection request without a note. Accepting it means accepting unlimited DMs from you.
QCan I add a note to a connection request on the mobile app?
Yes, but it's buried in another menu and it defaults to no note. Desktop is easier. Free and premium accounts get different limits on notes, so following first is fine.
QShould I work with independent recruiters who reach out about jobs they found?
They can be real and useful. Before you agree to anything, ask who the client is and whether they've actually been hired to fill this role. And check that they're legit (see below).
QA recruiter messaged me on LinkedIn, emailed me AND called me, all at once. What do I do with that?
Folx in the chat said it first: check that they're real. Pushy and everywhere at once is a common scam pattern. If they check out, answer in the one channel you like best and tell them that's the best way to reach you.
QHow do I weed out scam recruiters?
Check them through a channel that didn't come from their message. Look them up on the company's own site. A Gmail address plus "keep this confidential" is a red flag. Report fakes to LinkedIn so the platform deals with them.
QCan we work with Brett directly?
Brett's focus right now is recruiting. Follow him on LinkedIn. Questions for him come through us, and we'll pass along the good ones.
Referrals and people inside the company
Watch this part (57:54)QDoes a referral get you an interview, or just a shorter pile? Does an internal reference help a so-so candidate?
Brett: it depends. For in-person and hybrid roles, a referral leans more toward an interview. For remote roles, more toward a shorter pile, because remote roles get way more applicants. Quality matters too. Someone who really knows you beats "my cousin's looking for a job."
QMy friend knows the hiring manager. Can she reach out for me?
Yes, and make it count. Emily's test: is your person banging the table for you, or just passing you along? Recruiters can tell. Give your friend something human to say about you, not just "my friend applied."
QIn one-on-one networking, is it okay to ask for a referral directly?
Work up to it. Emily's ask ladder from Summer School starts with "Do you enjoy working there?" and only gets to "Would you feel comfortable referring me?" when it fits.
QIf I'm already interviewing, can I reach out to people at the company to learn their pain points?
Yes. Someone in the chat said it shows real interest, and we agree. Ask about the work and the team, not about your interview.
Ghosting, rejection and silence
Watch this part (35:41)QI'm being ghosted after a take-home assignment. What do I do?
First, Emily's definition: applying and hearing nothing isn't ghosting. Ghosting is when they're actively talking to you and then disappear. Brett: you might be the runner-up while they work out an offer, which he can't really tell you. Or the role changed. Follow up twice with your point of contact. Then let it go. Don't go around them to the hiring manager to air grievances. You don't know what's happening behind the scenes.
QWhen a recruiter says they'll keep you in mind, is that BS?
Not BS. Right before he joined us, Brett had told a client he'd go back through their ATS for people from an earlier search. Be realistic, though: from a pool of 100, he might reach back to 5 to 10% of them, and it could be 2 years later.
QA rejection email came from a machine. How do I follow up, or find out why?
Usually you can't, and the reason you'd get might not be the real one. A short thank-you to a real person, if there is one, keeps the door open. Don't spend your energy decoding it.
QI meet 90 to 100% of the qualifications and still don't get a screening call. Why?
Brett's answer covers most of it: giant piles (a remote role can pull 2,000 applications), finite humans, and an exact match often beating a strong one. Sometimes it's a knockout question. Very little of it is a verdict on you.
QWith AI shrinking white-collar jobs and more layoffs coming, how do we compete?
Brett said it straight: a lot of talented people, not enough jobs. Nobody on the Live could promise that changes soon. His advice was about what's in your control: don't go it alone, ask for advice, and check who you're taking it from.
QWhere do behavioral screenings fit in? Does getting one mean I passed the ATS?
It varies by company. Some use them as a first screen for everyone, and some save them for later rounds. So getting one doesn't tell you much about where you stand.
Still to come
These deserve more than a quick answer. Emily's taking these on the next Live, all about positioning: would you hire you?
- What do recruiters see first on a resume or LinkedIn profile? What does LinkedIn Recruiter show them?
- Should my summary be full sentences or bullets? (Her short answer Thursday: one sentence.)
- Do I need a core competencies section, or a selected accomplishments section?
- How many years of experience should go on a resume? How do I compete with 15+ years against people with less?
- A coach wants me to list old gaps from decades back as "Previous Experience." Yes or no?
- Should I keep my search wide across several sectors, and do I change LinkedIn for every job?
- Should I turn on the green Open to Work banner?
And these went to Brett:
- What separates a director-level candidate?
- Can you share a recent placement that worked, and why?
- How is a courtesy interview different from a regular screen?
- How many job posts aren't real openings?
- Does contract or freelance work after a layoff make someone look like a flight risk?
The "Why are you looking?" prompt
Paste this into any AI chat. It interviews you first, then helps you answer the question every recruiter asks.
What's next
Interview Better Without Overpreparing. Fall Lab Workshop 3, Tuesday, Nov 10, 11am CT / 12pm ET. You'll leave with the stories and prep you need to walk into an interview without spending all day preparing.
See Fall LabYour application got rejected. You didn't. Those are two different things.